13. Listening Gallery: Time’s Effect

CHOICES
Listen to this movement from Bach’s Cantata No. 52. Does time have an effect on the material?

Time does not have an effect.
 Time does have an effect.
ANSWER
The opening section is reprised exactly and in its entirety. Time does not have an effect.
CHOICES
Listen to the second, third and fourth movements of Earl Kim’s Now and Then. The second movement, Thither, is reprised. Does time have an effect?
2nd movement:

3rd movement: 

4th movement:

Time does not have an effect.
 Time does have an effect.
ANSWER
The second movement song, Thither, is replayed identically. Time does not have an effect.
LISTEN
In this movement, the A-section melody returns twice. Do the theme and its accompaniment return identically or does time have an effect?

1st refrain:
Time does not have an effect.
 Time does have an effect.
2nd refrain:
Time does not have an effect.
 Time does have an effect.
ANSWER
The first refrain of the A-section is literal. The only change is that, when it returns after the B-section, the melody is played only once and then proceeds directly into the C-section.

A: The C-section is characterized by a new, faster underlying rhythm. When the A-section once again returns, the theme is the same but the accompaniment does not revert to its original speed as expected. Instead, the C-section’s faster rhythm continues, blurring the distinction between the two sections. Thus, Beethoven’s ending is rhythmically intensified.

LISTEN
In this movement, the A-section theme returns twice. Does time have an effect?

1st refrain:
Time does not have an effect.
 Time does have an effect.
2nd refrain:
Time does not have an effect.
 Time does have an effect.
ANSWER

The first refrain of the A-section is literal. The second begins identically, but then a haunting transformation takes place: The theme, which had been continuous, is broken up into fragments, separated by silences.

Time has had an effect! What musically motivates these silences? Compare the starting and stopping nature of the A′-section with this passage from earlier in the work:

Mozart never returns to the original A-section: The fragmented version is the last one we hear.

CHOICES
Listen to the following excerpt from Dmitri Shostakovich’s String Quartet No. 7. When the reprise of the opening occurs, does time have an effect on the material?

Time does not have an effect.
 Time does have an effect.
ANSWER
Yes, time has an effect. In the return, the theme is mainly plucked, rather than bowed. There are sudden interjections. The rhythms are also subtly changed.